The Poor Players of Steubenville staged an electric production this week. “Leave it to Psmith” told the story of two lovers anxious to marry– complete with a criminal plot, poems about mud and fairies, and an enigmatic man ready for any job you have to offer – provided it has nothing to do with fish.  

The play was written by the beloved British humorist, P.G. Wodehouse, who was once called “the greatest musician of the English language.” Author Evelyn Waugh once wrote: “Mr. Wodehouse’s world can never stale. He will continue to release future generations from captivity that may be more irksome than our own. He has made a world for us to live in and delight in.” It was into this world that the Poor Players plunged their audiences. 

The script was crisp, clean, and vibrant—constant but unwearying in its expert humor. But all the more praiseworthy was the production itself—directed by Micaela Stoutz and Madison McCalister—which raised the energetic text to life. The actors showcased vivacity, larger-than-life characters and acute timing. In the titular role, Thomas Quackenbush held the audience in the palm of his hand. 

“I loved ‘Leave it to Psmith’!” recounted one attendee. “The sharp wit and face paced dialogue had me absolutely riveted throughout the play.”  

Another audience member gave glowing praise: “The play punched above its weight for a local production. Both charming and funny, it leaves its viewers reminiscing on silly one-liners and memorable plot twists.” 

“It was a blast,” shared co-director and actress Micaela Stoutz. “It was a lot of fun.” And the joy of the cast and crew was evident on the stage. The play lightened hearts and was clearly enjoyed by its audience.